Colorado Gold Review (2026): Bullion-Only Dealer With Posted Prices

Home » Blog » Top 10 Best Gold IRA Companies (2025) » Colorado Gold Review (2026): Bullion-Only Dealer With Posted Prices

Disclosure: We are reader-supported. If you purchase from a link on our site, we may earn a commission.  Learn more

Last Updated on: 17th November 2026, 02:48 pm

Some of the most honest pricing pages I have come across in this industry belong to companies almost nobody has heard of. Colorado Gold, a family-run bullion dealer in Montrose, Colorado, is one of them. It has been selling metal since 1977, posts its prices online, publishes its commission in plain English and refuses to carry rare coins at all. What it does not have is a crowd of online reviews, and that is why this review comes without a star score.

Noble Gold free 2026 investment kit
Prefer a company that handles the whole gold IRA for you?

Colorado Gold sells bullion but leaves the IRA paperwork to you. Noble Gold, our top-rated gold IRA company, sets up the account and rollover for you. Its free 2026 kit explains how it works.

Get the Free 2026 Kit

Content doesn't constitute financial advice. Speak to your financial advisor before making any investment decision. We may earn a commission if you purchase through one of our links.

Brief Overview
Founded1977, Montrose, Colorado
OwnershipFamily owned; David Stott listed as broker and owner
ProductsGold, silver, platinum and palladium bullion only (no rare coins)
PricingPosted online; 1% commission included in listed prices, lower on large orders
IRA custodianYour choice; Colorado Gold recommends none and takes no custodian compensation
BBBA+, accredited since 2010, no complaints in the last 3 years
Address222 S 5th St, Montrose, CO 81401
Phone(888) 786-8822
Our Verdict
Not rated GIG Global Rating

Colorado Gold checks almost every box we care about: 49 years in business, an A+ BBB record with no recent complaints, posted prices, a disclosed commission and bullion only. We are not scoring it because it has too few independent customer reviews to measure (three on Trustpilot, none on Google that we could find), and our method needs at least 10 on a platform.

Best for self-directed buyers who want plain bullion at a transparent price. Less suited to anyone who wants a company to run their IRA rollover.

Compare it with our ranking of the best gold IRA companies further down this page and talk to your financial advisor before moving retirement money. Last verified November 17, 2026. See how we rate gold IRA companies.

Who Is Colorado Gold?

Colorado Gold was founded in 1977 by Don Stott, who retired from the business in 2015, and it has stayed family owned. Its BBB profile lists David Stott as broker and owner, with brokers Melissa Thompson and Morgen Gaskell, at 222 S 5th St in Montrose. The website still carries Don’s Column, a long-running series of market commentary, and it says plainly that calls are recorded for accuracy.

This is a small, old-school operation. You will not find celebrity endorsements, free-silver promotions or a sales team chasing you. I first came across Colorado Gold years ago when a reader sent me its price list and asked whether it was “too cheap to be real.” It was real; it just did not spend money on advertising.

Colorado Gold Pricing and Fees

According to its how-to-purchase page, Colorado Gold charges a 1% commission that is already included in the prices on its site, with insured shipping covered by that fee. Orders over $50,000 pay 0.75% and orders of $100,000 or more pay 0.5%. Once you confirm a trade and receive a trade number, the price is locked.

  • Payment: wire, personal check, cashier’s check or ACH. Credit cards are not accepted, and larger or first-time orders may need a wire before the trade is placed.
  • Clearing times: ACH payments clear for 5 business days and checks for 7 business days before metal ships.
  • Shipping: UPS 2nd Day by default, or USPS Registered Mail on request.

Because prices are posted, you can check them against live spot prices before you call, which is exactly the comparison most phone-quote companies make difficult.

What Colorado Gold Sells

The catalog covers gold, silver, platinum and palladium coins and bars, including sovereign bullion coins such as the American Gold Buffalo, Canadian Maple Leaf, Australian Kangaroo, American Silver Eagle and American Platinum Eagle, plus bars from refiners like Valcambi and Sunshine Mint. Its homepage states that it does not carry rare coins, and the company has long argued that they are a poor investment. If you want to understand why that matters, my guide to proof, uncirculated and bullion coins breaks down the difference.

American Gold Buffalo bullion coin
American Gold Buffalo
American Silver Eagle bullion coin
American Silver Eagle
Canadian Gold Maple Leaf bullion coin
Canadian Gold Maple Leaf
Canadian Silver Maple Leaf bullion coin
Canadian Silver Maple Leaf
Australian Gold Kangaroo bullion coin
Australian Gold Kangaroo
American Platinum Eagle bullion coin
American Platinum Eagle
What we have observed about Colorado Gold’s model
  • Colorado Gold is one of the few dealers I review that sells only standard bullion. Across the quotes I have collected, bullion carries the lowest premium over spot and is the easiest metal to sell to almost any dealer later.
  • Its pricing page states the commission outright: 1% built into the listed price, 0.75% on orders over $50,000 and 0.5% at $100,000 or more. Most gold IRA companies quote by phone instead, so this level of disclosure is unusual.
  • Proof and collector coins are not on the menu at all. They can be beautiful, and a minority do gain collector value, but there is no guarantee a buyer recoups their extra premium; that is the trade-off Colorado Gold has chosen to avoid.
  • The catch is service rather than price: you open your own IRA custodian account, payments clear before metal ships, and there is no rollover concierge.
Questions worth asking before you order
  • What is the all-in price per ounce, and how does it compare with today’s spot price?
  • If I sold this exact product back next month, what would the bid be?
  • Does my IRA custodian accept every product on my order?

My personal take: I believe standard bullion at a disclosed markup is the better investment for most people’s metal allocation. That is my opinion, not a recommendation for your situation.

This is general information based on our research, not financial advice. Speak with your financial advisor before making any investment decision.

Using Colorado Gold for a Gold IRA

Colorado Gold sells IRA-eligible metal but does not set up the account. Its precious metals IRA page says it recommends no custodian and receives no compensation from any of them. You open a self-directed IRA with a custodian that allows physical metals, fund it with cash, and place the order; Colorado Gold ships the metal to the depository in your name. When you sell, it funds your IRA with cash after the transfer.

It links to New Direction IRA and STRATA Trust as custodians it has worked with; you can read our New Direction IRA review or browse our custodian reviews to compare fees. The metal itself must meet the IRS rules on coins and bullion in retirement accounts, so confirm eligibility with your custodian before you buy.

Third-Party Ratings at a Glance (2026)

Colorado Gold has a clean record, but very few independent reviews. Under our method, platforms with fewer than 10 reviews do not count toward a score.

PlatformRatingDetails
BBB⭐ A+ (accredited since 2010)No complaints in the last 3 years; business started in 1977
Trustpilot⭐ 4.0 (3 reviews, not counted)All three are 5-star reviews praising delivery speed and website pricing
Google⭐ No listing foundWe could not find a Google Business profile for the Montrose office

👍 Pros of Colorado Gold

  • Bullion only: no rare, proof or “exclusive” coin upsell
  • Prices posted online, with the commission disclosed (1%, falling to 0.75% over $50,000 and 0.5% at $100,000+)
  • Nearly five decades in business with an A+ BBB record and no recent complaints
  • No custodian kickbacks: you pick your own IRA custodian
  • Buys back metal it did not sell, with a published 1% charge

👎 Cons of Colorado Gold

  • Too few independent reviews for us to score
  • No in-house IRA setup help; you open the custodian account yourself
  • No credit cards; payment by wire, ACH or check, with clearing delays before shipment
  • $25 service charge and $50 wire fee on some sell orders

Selling Metal to Colorado Gold

Its selling page posts live bids that update about every 90 seconds and locks sell prices at the time of the trade. Colorado Gold buys metal it did not sell you, with a 1% charge, and a 0.5% commission applies to sellers who are not the original buyer. Orders without a commission carry a $25 service charge, wires cost $50, and you pay to ship the metal in, usually by USPS Registered Mail. Metal that arrives damaged may be paid less. For a broader look at the process, see our guide to selling gold and silver.

Who Colorado Gold Suits

Colorado Gold fits a self-directed buyer who wants plain bullion at a disclosed markup and is comfortable opening an IRA custodian account without help. It is a weaker fit if you want someone to manage a 401(k) rollover for you, need to pay by card, or want a company with hundreds of public reviews to lean on.

Noble Gold free 2026 investment kit
Want rollover help with a bullion-first approach?

Noble Gold focuses on standard bullion and handles the custodian setup and rollover paperwork. Request its free kit to compare fees.

Get Noble Gold’s Free Kit

Content doesn't constitute financial advice. Speak to your financial advisor before making any investment decision. We may earn a commission if you purchase through one of our links.

How Colorado Gold Compares

If you like the posted-price, bullion-first approach but want a larger dealer, our USAGOLD review covers another long-running bullion house, and our directory of gold dealers by state lists local options. The CFTC’s 10 questions to ask before buying metals are worth running through with any dealer, Colorado Gold included.

Contact Us if You Own or Represent Colorado Gold

If any detail in this review is out of date, or if you can point us to at least 10 independent customer reviews we have missed, contact us and we will re-check the facts and score the company.

Shopping for a Gold IRA?

See how the leading gold IRA companies compare in 2026, with fees, minimums, custodians and ratings side by side.

Colorado Gold FAQ

Is Colorado Gold legit?

Yes. Colorado Gold has operated since 1977, has been BBB accredited since 2010 with an A+ rating, and shows no BBB complaints in the last three years. We have not given it a star score only because it has very few independent customer reviews.

Does Colorado Gold publish its prices?

Yes. Prices are posted on its website and include a 1% commission, which drops to 0.75% on orders over $50,000 and 0.5% at $100,000 or more.

Does Colorado Gold sell rare or proof coins?

No. Its website says it does not carry rare coins and focuses on standard gold, silver, platinum and palladium bullion.

Can I use Colorado Gold for a gold IRA?

Yes, but you choose and open the self-directed IRA custodian yourself. Colorado Gold recommends no custodian, takes no custodian compensation, and ships IRA metal directly to your depository.

Will Colorado Gold buy back my gold?

Yes. It posts live bids and buys metal even if you bought it elsewhere, with a 1% charge in that case. Shipping to Colorado Gold is at your cost.

Why does Colorado Gold not have a GIG rating?

Our method excludes review platforms with fewer than 10 reviews. Colorado Gold has three Trustpilot reviews and no Google profile we could find, so there is not enough independent feedback to score it fairly.

Contact Us if You Own or Represent Colorado Gold

If you work for Colorado Gold and see anything in this review that is inaccurate or out of date, please get in touch. I update company reviews regularly and will correct anything that can be verified.

Sarah Bauder
Sarah Bauder

Sarah Bauder has a decade of experience at numerous publications, writing about finance, politics, economy and more.

Articles: 75

FTC Disclosure: We are an independent blog that aims at providing useful information for retirement account owners interested in alternative assets like precious metals. However, our content does NOT constitute financial advice. Please speak to your financial advisor before making any investment decision. Also, the data quoted on this website represents past performance and does not guarantee future results.

 

Copyright © 2026 Gold IRA Guide
×